The Campaign for Human Rights and Development International (CHRDI) has petitioned Sierra Leone’s Attorney General and the Judicial and Legal Service Commission (JLSC), challenging disciplinary proceedings and financial sanctions imposed on retired Supreme Court Justice Allan B. Halloway.
In a constitutional petition dated 21 November 2026, the civil society organisation alleged that actions taken against the former judge violated provisions of the 1991 Constitution and raised concerns about judicial independence and the right to a fair hearing.
The petition, signed by CHRDI Chief Executive Abdul M. Fatoma, calls for the restoration of withheld salaries and allowances, the removal of disputed disciplinary records and a review of recommendations made by a Constitutional Tribunal.
CHRDI said the disciplinary measures should be examined even though Justice Halloway has already retired after reaching the mandatory retirement age.
CHRDI Questions Withholding of Judge’s Allowances
According to the petition, Justice Halloway’s mid-month allowances were withheld for three consecutive months between June and August 2025.
CHRDI also alleged that his official fuel allocation was blocked and that reimbursements for medical expenses amounting to SLL 5,380.00 and official vehicle maintenance costs were refused.
The organisation further claimed that Justice Halloway was removed from all Court of Appeal and Supreme Court panels on which he served and was not assigned new cases.
CHRDI argued that these actions amounted to an unofficial suspension carried out before the JLSC adopted its resolution on 5 September 2025.
It cited Section 138 of the 1991 Constitution, which protects the salaries, allowances and conditions of service of Superior Court judges from changes to their disadvantage.
The organisation maintained that the Chief Justice did not have the constitutional authority to withhold the judge’s allowances or remove him from judicial duties as a disciplinary measure outside the prescribed procedures.
Organisation Challenges Decision to Place Judge on Half Salary
CHRDI also questioned the decision to place Justice Halloway on half salary following a suspension letter dated 15 September 2025.
According to the petition, the letter was signed by the Secretary to the President rather than the President and did not expressly state that the President had directed the suspension.
The organisation alleged that the Human Resource Management Office (HRMO) subsequently applied Rules 15.13 and 15.14 of the Civil Service Code and Rules to interdict the judge on half pay.
CHRDI argued that Superior Court judges are constitutional officeholders and should not be subjected to disciplinary procedures intended for civil servants.
It further stated that Rule 15.13 concerns civil servants indicted for criminal offences, while Justice Halloway had not been charged with or indicted for any criminal offence.
On that basis, the organisation described the decision to withhold 50% of his salary as unconstitutional.
These claims form part of CHRDI’s legal arguments and have not been established by a court ruling cited in the petition.
CHRDI Raises Concerns Over Fair Hearing
The petition also alleged that Justice Halloway was denied an opportunity to respond to the allegations against him before the JLSC made its representation to the President on 5 September 2025.
CHRDI said this raised questions under Section 23(1) of Sierra Leone’s Constitution, which provides protections relating to fair hearings.
The organisation also referred to a dissenting opinion issued by Justice Reginald S. Fynn on 22 September 2025.
According to CHRDI, Justice Halloway had submitted an ethics complaint on 11 September 2025 to the late Supreme Court Justice Ekundayo E. Roberts.
The complaint reportedly requested an investigation into the administrative measures taken against him.
CHRDI alleged that the complaint was not addressed and was later treated by the Constitutional Tribunal as evidence of insubordination.
The organisation argued that the sequence of events raised concerns about possible retaliation against a judge for using an established complaints procedure.
Tribunal Recommendations Questioned After Retirement
Another issue raised in the petition concerns the Constitutional Tribunal’s report dated 17 October 2026.
According to CHRDI, the tribunal recommended that Justice Halloway proceed on leave pending retirement.
It also recommended that failure to apologise for his conduct could constitute further misconduct sufficient to justify removal from office.
However, CHRDI stated that Justice Halloway had already retired upon reaching the mandatory retirement age before the tribunal issued its report.
The organisation argued that the recommendations were therefore beyond the tribunal’s legal powers.
CHRDI maintained that a retired judge could not be placed on leave pending retirement or removed from an office he no longer occupied.
The petition also questioned the tribunal’s composition, arguing that the involvement of a sitting Supreme Court justice who worked under the Chief Justice raised concerns about impartiality.
It further alleged that the tribunal continued its proceedings despite being informed of a Supreme Court application challenging its composition.
CHRDI Demands Payment of Withheld Salaries
CHRDI has asked the Attorney General and Minister of Justice to issue a formal legal opinion on the application of civil service disciplinary rules to Superior Court judges.
The organisation wants the government to ensure payment of Justice Halloway’s outstanding salary, withheld allowances, fuel entitlements and verified medical and vehicle maintenance reimbursements.
It also requested that his pension and gratuity be paid without deductions arising from the disputed disciplinary measures.
CHRDI further urged the Attorney General to advise President Julius Maada Bio against implementing the tribunal’s recommendations concerning retirement leave and possible removal from office.
The organisation asked the Judicial and Legal Service Commission to remove the disputed interdiction order from the judiciary’s administrative records.
It also called for safeguards to prevent judicial allowances from being withheld or judges from being removed from court panels outside constitutionally prescribed disciplinary procedures.
Additionally, CHRDI recommended the introduction of automated case tracking and registry audits to address court backlogs and improve case management.
Petition Raises Questions About Judicial Independence
CHRDI said its intervention was intended to protect constitutional procedures governing judicial discipline rather than prevent judges from being held accountable.
The organisation acknowledged the importance of timely judgments, effective case management and judicial accountability but argued that disciplinary proceedings must comply with constitutional safeguards.
It cited provisions of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the United Nations Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary.
The petition was copied to President Julius Maada Bio, the Speaker of Parliament, the Human Rights Commission of Sierra Leone, the Ombudsman and the Sierra Leone Bar Association.
The allegations and legal interpretations reported in the petition represent CHRDI’s position. The document does not include responses from the Attorney General, the Judicial and Legal Service Commission, the Chief Justice or the Human Resource Management Office.
CHRDI is seeking action from the relevant authorities to address the disputed measures and establish safeguards for future judicial disciplinary proceedings.








